The role of friends in adolescent overweight and weight-related behaviors: a social network perspective.
Files
Date
2011
Authors
de la Haye, Kayla
Editors
Advisors
Wilson, Carlene June
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Type:
Thesis
Citation
Statement of Responsibility
Conference Name
Abstract
This thesis examined processes that may be driving the clustering and proposed “spread” of obesity amongst adolescent friends and within their wider friendship networks (Fowler & Christakis, 2008; Halliday & Kwak, 2009). Specifically, the aims were to determine 1) if similarities in weight status amongst friends were explained, at least to some extent, by their body mass indexes (BMIs) assimilating over time, and 2) whether this was underpinned by friends’ influence on obesity-related behaviors. Findings from two cross-sectional studies and one longitudinal study are presented in four papers, of which one has been published and the remaining three submitted for publication. Paper 1 examined associations between adolescents’ BMI and their school-based friendships longitudinally (N = 156), using stochastic actor-oriented models (SAOM) for social networks (Snijders, Steglich, & Schweinberger, 2007). Weight status was found to play a significant role in adolescents’ friendship choices, with overweight youth often marginalized by, and segregated from, their nonoverweight peers. Although there was a trend for friends’ BMIs to assimilate over the 16-month study, this effect was not statistically significant. Similarities in BMI amongst friends were therefore explained by friendship choices rather than “contagion” effects. The conditions under which overweight youth are marginalized by their peers were further explored in Paper 2. This study looked at the role of school classroom norms favoring healthiness, and specifically the norms endorsed by high-status students, in weightrelated marginalization amongst pre-adolescents. In this cross-sectional study (N = 503), exponential random graph models (ERGM) (Robins, Pattison, Kalish, & Lusher, 2007) were used to test for associations between weight status and friendships in school classes with weak versus strong health norms. Overweight students, and particularly overweight girls, were found to be marginalized by their peers in classes with strong health norms; however overweight youth were well integrated in classrooms lacking clear norms on healthiness. The results suggest that local norms may impact the relevance of attributes like weight status to adolescent friendships and thus the prevalence of weight-based stigma in peer groups, providing some useful insights for future interventions. Whether weight-related health behaviors clustered and spread amongst adolescent friends was investigated in the final two papers. The first, cross-sectional, study (Paper 3) looked at several obesity-related behaviors within three adolescent friendship networks (N = 385) and tested for similarities amongst friends using ERGMs. The strongest evidence of behavioral similarity was found for organized physical activity (PA); therefore the final paper
(Paper 4) longitudinally examined the social processes driving this association using SAOMs (N = 378). Similarities in PA amongst friends over their first year of high school were found
to be explained by friendship selection and influence: adolescents were likely to befriend peers whose attitudes towards PA, and engagement in PA, were similar to their own; and
adolescents subsequently emulated their friends’ behaviors so that friends’ participation in PA became increasingly alike. Friends’ influence on PA was not found to be mediated via adolescents’ beliefs about PA, including their perceptions of peer norms, suggesting that this influence process was less internalized than some health behavior theories would suggest (e.g., Ajzen, 1991). As a whole, the studies presented in this thesis suggest that the clustering of overweight in adolescent friendship networks is initially driven by processes of weight-based friendship selection and the marginalization of overweight adolescents by their peers. Excess weight was not found to be contagious in the short term, and longer studies applying similar methods are needed. Nonetheless, some obesity-related behaviors were found to cluster in friendship networks, and for PA this was partially explained by adolescents adopting their friends’ behaviors. Friends’ influence on adolescent PA, and potentially other obesity-related behaviors, is a plausible mechanism that could result in the contagion of obesity in the longer-term. Intervening in, and potentially harnessing these social processes, provides a means to foster peer contexts that encourage healthy behaviors and help to reduce young people’s obesity risk in future.
School/Discipline
School of Psychology
Dissertation Note
Thesis (Ph.D.) -- University of Adelaide, School of Psychology, 2011
Provenance
Copyright material removed from digital thesis. See print copy in University of Adelaide Library for full text.