Power imbalance and power shift between Chinese international research students and their supervisors: adaptation and resilience
Date
2023
Authors
Xing, C.
Mu, G.M.
Henderson, D.
Editors
Mu, G.M.
Dooley, K.
Dooley, K.
Advisors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Type:
Book chapter
Citation
Source details - Title: Bourdieu and Sino-Foreign Higher Education: Structures and Practices in Times of Crisis and Change, 2023 / Mu, G.M., Dooley, K. (ed./s), Ch.7, pp.104-123
Statement of Responsibility
Conference Name
Abstract
For international research students, dealing with the ‘delicate’ student–supervisor relationship constitutes one of the greatest challenges when pursuing a research degree overseas. Much literature considers the subaltern status of students and the positional advantage of supervisors as academics within the higher education field. Informed by and different from this literature, this chapter investigated the ways in which power evolves, operates, and shifts between Chinese international research students and their supervisors during their research journey in Australian universities. Drawing on Bourdieu’s sociology, this study analysed 18 Chinese international research students’ viewpoints on student–supervisor relationships and identified ‘power imbalance’ and ‘power shift’ between Chinese international HDR students and their supervisors. The findings suggest profound power imbalance in three interdependent aspects, that is, perceived supervisor authority, student consent to supervisor authority, and students’ self-perceived deficiency. Notably, power shift—traces of resilience to symbolic violence—were also identified, including empowerment by supervisors, students’ accumulation of scholarly authority and autonomy, and students’ resistance. By dint of these findings, some important pedagogical implications in negotiating power are proposed for (international) research students, supervisors, universities, and powerful institutions.
School/Discipline
Dissertation Note
Provenance
Description
Access Status
Rights
Copyright 2023 selection and editorial matter, Guanglun Michael Mu and Karen Dooley; individual chapters, the contributors